thank you for sharing your thoughts on things. I just need to point out that they do not define GBD so that anyone reading who is actually looking for definitions (which is the purpose of the thread
) will not be confused by the thoughts you've added. If you'd like to start more specific threads (and I know you did start one already, but maybe more specific ones) we can talk about it more.
Certainly no one can impose a natural consequence--that's just not possible. But Solutions (a la Jane Nelson) are beautiful teaching tools. They are not punitive logical consequences though.
You seem to be arguing against punishment and yet there is no presentation of punishments here