I have silicone cupcake "tins" and I do like that they're easy but they bake differently and slower and have a funny smell when cooking. I don't really use them. I did buy individual silicone cupcake liners and those were amazing! Kids lost them all
I have wondered if the cupcake tins are just cheap (they were a gift) and if that makes a difference. I never wanted to buy a mat based on my experience with those.